What should you never hand to a machine?

The real risk of AI is not that it fails. It is quiet deskilling through convenience: handing over judgement, hard conversations and complex problems one convenient decision at a time.

The cede/keep test helps you decide, task by task, what you should keep, what you can share with AI and what you can safely cede, and spot where you are already drifting. It takes about 35 minutes on your own, and works best when you then talk it through with your team.

Page one of the cede/keep test: which parts of your work should you keep, with four steps to use the kit

Three tests and one honest question

Every task sits somewhere between work you hold yourself and work AI does for you. Three questions decide where a task should sit. One honest question shows where it sits today. The gap between the two is what matters.

1. Recovery

If your AI tools stopped working tomorrow, would you struggle to do this well?

Why we ask: tools fail, change and reprice. Capabilities like judgement and relationships take years to rebuild.

A tick means: keep it in practice.

2. Supervision

Do you need to be good at this to spot when AI gets it wrong?

Why we ask: you can only check AI's work if you can do the work yourself. Lose the skill and you lose the check.

A tick means: you need to keep your hand in.

3. Development

Does doing this yourself grow you, or someone you lead?

Why we ask: some tasks are how people learn. Cede the task and the growth goes with it.

A tick means: the doing matters, not just the result.

Today

How much of this does AI already do: Little, Some or Most?

Why we ask: this is not scored with a tick. It shows where the task actually sits, so be honest about what happens, not what should.

Your answer is the "today" marker.

Count the ticks to find where it should sit

KeepYou hold the judgement. AI might help you prepare, but the thinking and the call are yours.2 or 3 ticks
ShareAI does part of the work. You shape it, check it and own the result.1 tick
CedeSafe for AI to do, with a light check. Ceding it frees your time.0 ticks

Then read the gap from the grid

Scoring grid: where a task should sit, against how much AI does today
Should sitAI does little todayAI does someAI does most
KeepHoldingDriftingDrifting
ShareRoom to cedeHoldingDrifting
CedeRoom to cedeRoom to cedeHolding
  • Holding: AI does about as much as it should. The real test is whether it stays there when time is short.
  • Drifting: AI does more than it should, so take some back. It rarely happens in one decision: it is one convenient shortcut at a time.
  • Room to cede: AI could safely do more, freeing your time for the work you keep.

What's in the kit

Page one: how to use the kit, in four steps with timings
1. Start hereHow to use the kit in four steps, on your own or with your team, and how often.
Page two: three places a task can sit, the gap between should sit and today, and the four questions
2. What the test is asking, and whyKeep, Share and Cede, the gap, and the four questions you answer for each task.
Page three: how to test a task, the scoring grid, one task step by step and worked examples
3. How to test a taskFive steps, the scoring grid, the board update worked through and more examples.
Page four: the blank worksheet for six of your own tasks, with the scoring grid
4. My worksheetTest six of your own tasks, with the grid beside you. Print it at A3 for team sessions.
Page five: talk it through with a colleague and your team, then commit to what you will keep, the task you are drifting on and one thing you could cede
5. Talk it through and commitChallenge questions, then the tasks you will keep, the one you are drifting on and one thing you could cede.

Get the test kit

Tell us who you are and the download starts straight away.

Add your first name.

Add your last name.

Enter an email address like name@organisation.com.

Add your organisation.

Done the test? Talk it through with us

Book a free 30 minute debrief with a Managing Consultant. Bring your test kit, or your team's keep list. We'll help you read the drift, test the keep list against what your organisation needs, and agree what to do first.